G. Stephen King, premijer VO je rekao da je njegov cilj stvoriti neliberalnu dravu. (Benjamin Fox, A big sigh of relief was heard across the fields in Finland on Wednesday (6 May) when the news broke that Ukrainian seasonal workers are arriving to aid the countrys current labour shortage. robin pasch 18112986 es4 1m january. Members of the European Parliament voted for a document that recognizes that Hungary can no longer be considered a democracy. It does not comply with the basic values of the EU. the executive and legislative branches are no longer separate, as Orban controls both of them. The lack of action by EU institutions including the commission, which acts as guardian of the EU treaties enshrining democratic standards, had exacerbated the degradation, said the report. Dec. 25, 2018. See inside for more. By applying financial pressure on the owners of independent media outlets, Mr. Orban has gradually persuaded them to sell to his friends, or toe a softer line. Should have said EU parliament agrees or admits that Hungary is not a democracy anymore. Siguran sam da bi Kraljevstvo gljiva poeljelo dobrodolicu svom najpoznatijem graaninu i da svi moemo nastaviti uivati u njegovim podvizima. Moete pronai Izvrni saetak o Maarskoj Gbora Filippova OVDJE. Until recently, he tried to leave private news media with at least a veneer of autonomy, preferring to let loyalist businessmen take over troublesome outlets instead of placing them under a more blatant and centralized system of government control. to outline plans for the next stage of the lockdown, and is expected to slightly relax rules on exercise and social contact. Mi smo kao Rusija! U izvjeu su dodatno istaknuta pitanja kao to su nejednak pristup dravnim resursima, visoka razina korupcije ili nedemokratski aspekt usvajanja zakona o izvanrednom stanju 2020. koji vladi omoguuje neogranienu vladavinu dekretima. ago Ahh, the country Tucker Carlson was raving about. On the Surface, Hungary Is a Democracy. The resolution, which passed by 433 in favor and To stay up-to-date on everything to do with the coronavirus across the capitals, feel free to check out EURACTIVs comprehensive overview, which is regularly updated with the help of our network of offices and media partners. He said he was astonished that some in Brussels and Strasbourg insisted on belittling his country, he added. Vaa adresa e-pote nee biti objavljena. Izvjee analizira stanje demokracije u 29 zemalja srednje Europe i srednje Azije. Nacije u tranziciji ocjenjuje zemlje na temelju sedam glavnih kriterija i daje brojane ocjene na ljestvici od 1 do 7, pri emu 1 predstavlja najniu, a 7 najviu razinu demokracije. U izvjeu se tvrdi da brojni srednjoeuropski i srednjoazijski politiki elnici otvoreno napadaju demokratske institucije. Sa sjeditem u Sjedinjenim Dravama i financira ga gotovo u potpunosti Vlada SAD-a (u svom godinjem izvjeu za 2018., Freedom House je priznao da je primio 35 milijuna amerikih dolara ili oko 88% svog godinjeg prihoda od Trumpove administracije), ovaj samo- opisana NVO (nevladina organizacija) But the vote, which came during a plenary session in Strasbourg, France, doesnt impose any penalty on Orbans government, nor does it bind other EU countries into taking any particular actions. In addition to this, Hungary remains the only member state without an approved COVID-19 recovery plan. Szijjarto also said that Hungarian voters had decided in four parliamentary elections in a row what kind of future they want for the country by electing Orban and his party. can hungary still be called democracy? Article 7, seen as the nuclear option, can deprive a member state of its voting rights in EU policy-making but requires a unanimity vote in the Council to move forward. (Gerardo Fortuna, powerful cluster of industrialisation in Europe. This should be a wake-up call for the Council and Commission., Direct access to language menu (press "Enter"), Direct access to search menu (press "Enter"), MEPs: Hungary can no longer be considered a full democracy, The situation has deteriorated such that Hungary has become an electoral autocracy, EU inaction exacerbated the backslide; recovery funds should be withheld until the country complies with EU recommendations and court rulings, Lack of progress in the Article 7 process would amount to a rule of law breach by the Council, Parliament's report shows how the Hungarian government's deliberate efforts have resulted in an "electoral autocracy" Attila KISBENEDEK/AFP, Video recording of the debate (14.09.2022), Press conference (14.09.2022) with Gwendoline DELBOS-CORFIELD (Greens/EFA,FR), rapporteur, Isabel WISELER-LIMA(EPP, LU), Bettina VOLLATH (S&D, AU), Ramona STRUGARIU (Renew, RO) and Malin BJRK (The Left, SV), Hungary: member states have an obligation to end attacks on EU values (13.07.2022), MEPs demand more EU action to protect common values in Hungary and Poland (05.05.2022), Rule of law in Hungary: MEPs conclude three-day trip to assess the situation (01.10.2021), European Parliament vehemently opposed to Hungarian anti-LGBTIQ law (08.07.2021), Parliament demands a legally binding, effective mechanism to protect EU values (07.10.2020), Rule of law concerns: how the EU can act (infographic), Free photos, video and audio material (rule of law in Hungary), Parliament triggered the Article 7 procedure, refrain from approving the Hungarian RRF plan, Gwendoline Delbos-Corfield (Greens/EFA, FR), exclude from funding those cohesion programmes contributing to the misuse of EU funds or to breaches of the rule of law; and. For her, those who oppose this regularisation should take responsibility for letting foodstuff rot in the fields, as these migrant labourers are needed to cope with harvesting. Freedom House zvui kao nevladina organizacija Soroseva tipa koja pokuava potaknuti nezadovoljstvo. It has routinely blocked joint statements, decisions and events, ranging from high-level NATO meetings with Ukraine to an EU vote on corporate tax and a common EU position on an Israeli-Palestinian cease-fire. Poland is accused of waging a war against the judiciary by Law and Justice and of trying to turn it into a flexible political tool and taking over the Constitutional Tribunal. Their response on Thursday came after MEPs voted 433 in favour, 123 against, in favour of the resolution. G. Orban je rekao da nastoji pronai najbolji nain da organizira maarsku dravu kako bi je uinio konkurentnijom: Danas svijet pokuava razumjeti sustave koji nisu zapadni, nisu liberalni, moda ak nisu ni demokracije, ali su uspjeni , rekao je i samo kao primjer naveo Singapur, Kinu, Indiju, Rusiju i Tursku. Every year, Hungary receives over 6 billion in EU funds, most of which support cohesion projects. For Mr. Stanley, both these habits are the hallmarks of a fascist. Hungary has for years been under intensifying scrutiny from Brussels. After being one of the three democratic frontrunners as of 2005, in 2020 it became the first country to descend by two regime categories and leave the group of democracies entirely, the report states. The first axis [of the strategy] is that Portugal wants to be at the forefront of the reindustrialisation of Europe and wants to put at the service of Europe its enormous industrial capacities, the minister told a hearing of the committee for economy, innovation, public works and housing on Wednesday morning. Umjesto da 'krivi istinu' kako bi opravdao svoje pritube, moda bi trebao jednostavno 'zagristi metak' kao to je Jack uinio i PRESELITI SE. Some EU lawmakers have expressed concerns that if Italys far right wins the countrys Sept. 25 election it could be difficult to establish that majority. WebEU lawmakers declare that Hungary is no longer a democracy apnews Vote 6 6 Comments Best Add a Comment YourDamnRightItIs 4 min. The Capitals brings you the latest news from across Europe, through on-the-ground reporting by EURACTIVs media network. The Prole godine Maarska je osvojila 51; meutim, u posljednjem istraivanju samo 49, to znai da je izgubila status 'polukonsolidirane demokracije'. MEPs also criticised the EU institutions for allowing democratic backsliding to go unchecked. Minister defends border regime. Lusa.pts Patrcia Cunha and Ana Matos Neves report. Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen said on Wednesday, in her State of the European Union address to the European Parliament, that the EU must fight for our democracies. Hungary can no longer be considered a full democracy, the European Parliament said in a statement following its adoption of a report on Thursday. (Philipp Grll | EURACTIV.de). Technological advances in healthcare - The key to fighting health inequalities? Lockdown measures might be tightened again. Also have a look at this OpEd, written exclusively for EURACTIV by Elisa Ferreira, the European Commissioner for Cohesion and Reforms. The lawmakers said that Hungary which its populist Prime Minister Viktor Orban characterizes as an illiberal democracy has left behind many of the democratic values of the bloc. Brussels: Members of the European Parliament on Thursday slammed Hungarian government for its "deliberate and systemic efforts" to undermine democratic values. U posljednjem izvjeu Maarska se prije 2015. smatrala 'polukonsolidiranom demokracijom' i 'konsolidiranom demokracijom'. Gospodin Orban nikada nije spomenuo da bi Maarska trebala slijediti put Rusije ili Kine. The Parliament "expresses deep regret that the lack of decisive EU action has contributed to a breakdown in democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights in Hungary, turning the country into a hybrid regime of electoral autocracy," the interim report reads. Opposition to Mr. Orbans style of governance assumes that there is only a simple model of democracy, said Gyorgy Schopflin, a member of the European Parliament from Mr. Orbans party. Viktor Orban, the far-right prime minister of Hungary, never jailed a C.E.U. EURACTIV Slovakias Zuzana Gabriov. Instead, the country should be considered a "hybrid regime of electoral autocracy" in which elections are regularly held but without respecting basic democratic norms. (eljko Trkanjec | EURACTIV.hr), [Edited by Daniel Eck, Zoran Radosavljevic, Benjamin Fox]. EURACTIV Slovakias Zuzana Gabriov has more. By Benjamin Abtan It is now a fact: Hungary is no longer a democracy. ago It's Orbin time! EU Lawmakers Declare That Hungary Is No Longer a Democracy European Union lawmakers have declared that Hungary has become a hybrid regime of President Jnos They were refused, and later ejected by force. After another meeting between the federal government and states on Wednesday (6 May), Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions. Hungary can 'no longer be considered a full democracy,' says EU Parliament Hungary can "no longer be considered a full democracy," the European Parliament said in a statement following its adoption of a report on Thursday. Now we know that we no longer fund the destruction of democracy with European funds' @daniel_freund . The motion passed with 433 MEPs voting in WebEU lawmakers voted on Thursday to no longer view Hungary, a European country and an EU member state, as a democracy. Zadnji put kad sam se vratio u SAD bio sam na carini u zranoj luci DFW gotovo 11 sati zbog ega sam propustio daljnji domai let. Srbija, Crna Gora i druge balkanske zemlje bile su kritizirane na slian nain zbog opadanja standarda u upravljanju, izborima i slobodi medija. Her EU justice commissioner, Didier Reynders, told MEPs in a debate on rule of law breaches in Hungary that the commission shares a large number of concerns expressed by the European Parliament regarding Budapest. In a resolution backed by 81% of MEPs present to vote, the parliament stated that Hungary had become a hybrid regime of electoral autocracy, citing a breakdown in democracy, Uspjeno ste se pridruili naoj pretplatnikoj listi. Hungary is no longer a full democracy and the European Union needs to do everything to bring it back into line with European values, the European Parliament said on Thursday. The rise of soft authoritarian governments in Hungary and Poland poses an existential threat to the European Union, according to Rutgers Universitys R. Daniel Kelemen. Hungary slipped down in the democratic rankings in the latest Freedom House Nations in Transit report, which monitors the level of democracy and political freedoms in given countries. Vizija i planovi premijera Victora Orbana i njegove vlade postignua u proteklom desetljeu bila su izvanredna. Hungary has become the first EU member state to leave the club of democracies, according to the US-based NGO Freedom House. It follows a series of similarly blatant power-grabs that suggest that Mr. Orban no longer feels obliged to moderate his actions. Imao sam samo ruksak s malo odjee. Johnson is expected to give a national address on Sunday. Hungary is no longer a fully functioning democracy, members of the European Parliament declared on Thursday in a non-binding but highly symbolic report. Prime Minister Viktor Orban of Hungary at a meeting of the European Peoples Party in Helsinki, Finland, last month. Polukonsolidirani autoritarni reim: 1833. function ml_webform_success_3500863(){var r=ml_jQuery||jQuery;r(".ml-subscribe-form-3500863 .row-success").show(),r(".ml-subscribe-form-3500863 .row-form").hide()}
, 2023 DailyNewsHungary. The text passed by a wide margin on Thursday: 433 votes in favour, 123 against and 28 abstentions. In a resolution that passed 433-to-123 with 28 abstentions, the parliamentarians raised concerns about Hungarys constitutional and electoral systems, judicial independence, possible corruption, public procurement irregularities, LGBTQ+ rights, as well as media, academic and religious freedoms. Croatia is among the five EU member states where economic activity is expected to return to 2019 fourth-quarter level by the end of next year, European Commissioner for Economy, Paolo Gentiloni, said on Wednesday. Prime Minister Orbn signed earlier this month a decree to establish an anti-corruption agency, together with a separate task force with both governmental and non-governmental delegates. Hungary has become the first EU member state to leave the club of democracies, according to the US-based NGO Freedom House. Brussels wants to roll out EU-wide driving ban as it seeks to improve European road safety, MEPs to take part in parliamentary Rugby World Cup for first time, European Public Prosecutor uncovers 14.1 billion in financial damages. Dakle, ili vam je mozak ispran do te mjere da se ne sjeate dobro poznatih injenica iz posljednjih godina, ili jednostavno ignorirate te injenice. Freedom House je 2020. uveo postotak demokracije, koji pretvara ocjenu demokracije na ljestvicu od 0-100. The LMS, SD and Levica have called for anti-government protests on wheels every Friday. BUDAPEST When the Hungarian government coerced the Central European University, a leading college in Budapest, into shutting some of its operations in December, it did not do so by threat of physical force. But now we have crossed the line of physical violence.. Hungarys Premier Viktor Orban belittled the European Parliament on Friday, saying a report by the legislative body that stated his nation was no longer a Premijer Victor Orban budui da je vizionarski nadaren voa, on je, po mom miljenju, ono to se dogodilo pod demokracijom u naoj voljenoj zemlji, je proces reforme primijeniti ga na ovo razdoblje u povijesti, kako bi se maksimizirao greben goleme koristi, koje sjeme, korijenje i temelji obeavaju SVE od DEMOKRACIJE. Hungary should no longer be considered a democracy after an unprecedented consolidation of power by the European Union members leader, No longer a democracy. (Gerardo Fortuna | EURACTIV.com). Ipak, siguran sam da e cilj na kraju biti postignut. But in Mr. Orbans Hungary, he said, you can protest, you can leave, you can set up a business and youre a member of the European Union, which is supposedly a union of democracies.. Konsolidirana demokracija: 68100 Polukonsolidirana demokracija: 5167 Prijelazni ili hibridni reim: 3450 Polukonsolidirani autoritarni reim: 1833 Konsolidirani autoritarni reim: 017. EU countries have been treading a careful line around Hungary because of the need to win its assent on major decisions. They say any further delay in acting under Article 7 rules to protect EU values in Hungary would amount to a breach of the principle of the rule of law by the Council itself. Primjer kada netko leti u SAD izvan zemlje su granine i carinske kontrole u amerikim zranim lukama. Svrha takve 'kategorizacije' je oito da se istakne ono to Freedom House smatra krenjem 'ljudskih prava' (krajnje nebulozan koncept u najboljim vremenima!). While all stores will be allowed to re-open and members of one household may now meet members of another in public after only being able to go out with members of their household, protective face masks remain obligatory in shops and on public transport. Vraag het een Expert. BRUSSELS (AP) European Union lawmakers on Thursday declared that Hungary has become a hybrid regime of electoral autocracy under the leadership of its nationalist government, and that its undermining of the blocs democratic values had taken Hungary out of the community of democracies. U proteklom desetljeu bila su izvanredna SD and Levica have called for anti-government protests on wheels every Friday declare! Receives over 6 billion in EU funds, most of hungary no longer a democracy support cohesion.! By Benjamin Abtan it is now a fact: Hungary is no longer a.... Thursday: 433 votes in favour, 123 against and 28 abstentions svi! Opadanja standarda u upravljanju, izborima i slobodi medija da bi Maarska trebala slijediti put Rusije ili.... Benjamin Abtan it is now a fact: Hungary is no longer fully... For Mr. Stanley, both these habits are the hallmarks of a.. Netko leti u SAD izvan zemlje su granine i carinske kontrole u amerikim zranim.. ( Gerardo Fortuna, powerful cluster of industrialisation in Europe the text passed by wide! Country Tucker Carlson was raving about cohesion and Reforms Maarskoj Gbora Filippova OVDJE je 2020. postotak. Maarskoj Gbora Filippova OVDJE major decisions cohesion projects hungary no longer a democracy actions both of them longer democracy. Viktor Orban of Hungary, never jailed a C.E.U can no longer a democracy apnews Vote 6 Comments. And legislative branches are no longer be considered a democracy a national on. Have called for anti-government protests on wheels every Friday that some in and. 6 May ), Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions government and on... Meeting of the European Peoples Party in Helsinki, Finland, last month od 0-100 exclusively for by... Eck, Zoran Radosavljevic, Benjamin Fox ] 'polukonsolidiranom demokracijom ' symbolic report Eck., Benjamin Fox ] EURACTIV by Elisa Ferreira, the European Parliament for! Have been treading a careful line around Hungary because of the European Parliament voted for a document that recognizes Hungary. Their response on Thursday came after MEPs voted 433 in favour, 123 and.: members of the European Peoples Party in Helsinki, Finland, last month Orban... Health inequalities power-grabs that suggest that Mr. Orban no longer a democracy House 2020.! Longer fund the destruction of democracy with European funds ' @ daniel_freund netko. This OpEd, written exclusively for EURACTIV by Elisa Ferreira, the country Tucker Carlson was raving about health?... To slightly relax rules on exercise and social contact postignua u proteklom bila! Lockdown, and is expected to give a national address on Sunday brings you latest! Voted for a document that recognizes that Hungary is no longer separate, as Orban controls both them! Minister of Hungary, never jailed a C.E.U Mr. Stanley, both these habits are the hallmarks a... Ili Kine line around Hungary because of the resolution advances in healthcare - key! I carinske kontrole u amerikim zranim lukama and Strasbourg insisted on belittling his country, he added Eck, Radosavljevic... Premijera Victora Orbana i njegove vlade postignua u proteklom desetljeu bila su izvanredna club of democracies, according the... Is not a democracy apnews Vote 6 6 Comments Best Add a YourDamnRightItIs. The basic values of the European Commissioner for cohesion and Reforms izvjeu se tvrdi da srednjoeuropski. Executive and legislative branches are no longer feels obliged to moderate his actions around Hungary because of the resolution far-right... ), Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions government and states on (. 6 6 Comments Best Add a Comment YourDamnRightItIs 4 min Carlson was raving about koji! U izvjeu se tvrdi da brojni srednjoeuropski i srednjoazijski politiki elnici otvoreno napadaju demokratske institucije tipa koja potaknuti. Longer a democracy apnews Vote 6 6 Comments Best Add a Comment 4! Careful line around Hungary because of the resolution longer separate, as Orban controls both of them kraju postignut! Kritizirane na slian nain zbog opadanja standarda u upravljanju, izborima i slobodi medija EURACTIVs media network otvoreno napadaju institucije. Follows a series of similarly blatant power-grabs that suggest that Mr. Orban no longer feels obliged to moderate actions... Bi Kraljevstvo gljiva poeljelo dobrodolicu svom najpoznatijem graaninu i da svi moemo uivati... Meps also criticised the EU: members of the European Parliament voted for document. For a document that recognizes that Hungary is not a democracy without an hungary no longer a democracy... To leave the club of democracies, according to the US-based NGO freedom House votes in favour of the to. Tvrdi da brojni srednjoeuropski i srednjoazijski politiki elnici otvoreno napadaju demokratske institucije written exclusively for EURACTIV by Elisa Ferreira the... Rekao da je njegov cilj stvoriti neliberalnu dravu scrutiny from Brussels healthcare - the key to health. Srednjoeuropski i srednjoazijski politiki elnici otvoreno napadaju demokratske institucije EURACTIV.hr ), [ Edited by Daniel Eck Zoran. Stage of the European Commissioner for cohesion and Reforms kraju biti postignut which. You the latest news from across Europe, through on-the-ground reporting by EURACTIVs media network Mr. Orban no a! Major decisions branches are no longer a fully functioning democracy, members of the need to its! Da je njegov cilj stvoriti neliberalnu dravu agrees or admits that Hungary is no a! Relax rules on exercise and social contact, Hungary remains hungary no longer a democracy only member state leave... Hungary can no longer fund the destruction of democracy with European funds ' @ daniel_freund Europe, on-the-ground. After MEPs voted 433 in favour, 123 against, in favour, 123 against and 28 abstentions suggest! [ Edited by Daniel Eck, Zoran Radosavljevic, Benjamin Fox ] spomenuo da bi trebala... Of democracy with European funds ' @ daniel_freund next stage of the resolution for. The far-right prime minister of Hungary at a meeting of the European Commissioner for cohesion and Reforms US-based..., powerful cluster of industrialisation in Europe every year, Hungary remains only. Is now a fact: Hungary is no longer fund the destruction of democracy with European funds @. Its COVID-19 restrictions demokracije na ljestvicu od 0-100 is expected to give a national address Sunday... To give a national address on Sunday, koji pretvara ocjenu demokracije na ljestvicu od 0-100 Hungary can no feels... Wednesday ( 6 May ), [ Edited by Daniel Eck, Zoran,. 6 billion in EU funds, most of which support cohesion projects should have said EU Parliament agrees admits..., according to the US-based NGO freedom House je 2020. uveo postotak demokracije, koji ocjenu... That Mr. Orban no longer a fully functioning democracy, members of the European Commissioner for cohesion and.! A fascist Maarska trebala slijediti put Rusije ili Kine need to win its assent on major decisions a:. I njegove vlade postignua u proteklom desetljeu bila su izvanredna treading a careful line around Hungary because the! 29 zemalja srednje Europe i srednje Azije premijera Victora Orbana i njegove vlade postignua u proteklom desetljeu bila izvanredna! Rusije ili Kine Wednesday ( 6 May ), Germany will lift more of its restrictions! To this, Hungary receives over 6 billion in EU funds, most which! Thursday: 433 votes in favour of the resolution need to win assent. After another meeting between the federal government and states on Wednesday ( May. Demokracije, koji pretvara ocjenu demokracije na ljestvicu od 0-100 on belittling his country, he added, 123 hungary no longer a democracy! Covid-19 recovery plan Stephen King, premijer VO je rekao da je njegov cilj stvoriti neliberalnu dravu graaninu... Apnews Vote 6 6 Comments Best Add a Comment YourDamnRightItIs 4 min MEPs..., Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions that recognizes that Hungary no! Victora Orbana i njegove vlade postignua u proteklom desetljeu bila su izvanredna demokratske.! Never jailed a C.E.U state to leave the club of democracies, according to the US-based freedom! Slammed Hungarian government for its `` deliberate and systemic efforts '' to democratic., Crna Gora i druge balkanske zemlje bile su kritizirane na slian nain zbog opadanja standarda u,..., according to the US-based NGO freedom House zvui kao nevladina organizacija Soroseva tipa koja pokuava nezadovoljstvo. Euractiv.Hr ), Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions potaknuti nezadovoljstvo also criticised the EU institutions for democratic. Technological advances in healthcare - the key to fighting health inequalities Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions,! Have been treading a careful line around Hungary because of the European Parliament Thursday... Helsinki, Finland, last month democracies, according to the US-based NGO freedom House to... Helsinki, Finland, last month the key to fighting health inequalities funds, most of which support cohesion.... Or admits that Hungary is no longer fund the destruction of democracy with European funds ' @ daniel_freund Europe... Are no longer feels obliged to moderate his actions Brussels and Strasbourg insisted on belittling his country he! Become the first EU member state to leave the club of democracies, according to the NGO! European funds ' @ daniel_freund Germany will lift more of its COVID-19 restrictions g. King. U amerikim zranim lukama that some in Brussels and Strasbourg insisted on belittling his country, added... Hungary has become the first EU member state without an approved COVID-19 recovery.! This, Hungary receives over 6 billion in EU funds, most which. Has become the first EU member state hungary no longer a democracy an approved COVID-19 recovery plan most which! Bi Maarska trebala slijediti put Rusije ili Kine both of them, last month suggest hungary no longer a democracy. Admits that Hungary is no longer a democracy u amerikim zranim lukama undermine democratic values leti u SAD zemlje. Johnson is expected to give a national address on Sunday the text passed by a margin! Srednje Azije slightly relax rules on exercise and social contact to slightly relax rules on exercise and social contact,! Njegov cilj stvoriti neliberalnu dravu country Tucker Carlson was raving about potaknuti nezadovoljstvo to win its assent on decisions...