Through the exploration of Religion, Philosophy, Science, and History, you will uncover the roots of power that have made language one of the most influential forces in Human History. He was placed in special education, and clearly, Jerald lacked the conventional skills that mark literacy sentences, spelling, paragraphs but he didnt lack intelligence. A few students from the African American Literature class came to the faculty meeting the following Monday to share poems they had written during a workshop with Beaty. The same is true of language arts. I cant expect that students know how to write when they enter my classroom, especially when so many children these days have been pressed like tarnished pennies through mechanical curriculum that promises increased test scores and delivers thin imitation writing without a hint of originality anywhere on the page. Delve into Savathns Throne World, a twisted wonderland of corruption and splendor, to uncover the mystery of how she and her Lucent Hive stole the Light. How do we involve diverse groups of parents in our classrooms and schools? I had been struck over the years by how much school devalues the lives of blue-collar workers, divorcing manual work from intellectual work. Some days, to use Bill Bigelows description from the years when we taught together, it seemed like the students had thrown a party and I was the uninvited guest. Rethinking Bilingual Education is anapproachable collection of ideas that serve to inspire educators with new insights for centering the development of critical consciousness in a variety of settings., Jody Slavick,Bilingual Research Journal, In the tradition of Rethinking Schools, the publicationRethinking Bilingual Education does not shy away from exploring issues of privilege and power, race, language, and cultureeven with the youngest of studentsand sees public education as a transformative vehicle in society, and educators as political agents. Language encodes a way of conceiving of and being in the world. Her final words were in her village dialect. Specifically, this study unveils hidden structures and beliefs which hinder or promote immigrant womens use of heritage "And then I went to school" / by Joe Suina ; "Speak it good and strong" / by Hank Sims ; "The monitor" / by Wangari Maathai ; "Obituary" / by Lois-Ann Yamanaka ; "A piece of my heart/Pedacito de mi corazon" / by Carmen Lomas Garza They asked, Mu kesitokewn? (Youre not hurt?) And they are multiculturalthey seek out connections to other languages and other cultures. Through the exploration of Religion, Philosophy, Science, and History, you will uncover the roots of power that have made language one of the most influential forces in Human History. Random reflections on the power of language Democracy No single person or institution can monopolise language, however powerful they may be, as language is, by its nature, democratic. The group became my curricular conscience. Honing our craft takes time and multiple drafts. As more and more words emerged, I could finally rest: I had a place to stand for the first time in my life. What can we learn from Indigenous language immersion about the integral relationship between language and culture? There is joy because hes learned a craft that he felt beyond his reach; theres justice because Michael and his classmates learned to question policies that award or deny status based on race and class. Students in low-income communities are often tossed like loose change into overcrowded and underfunded classrooms where elementary teachers didnt have enough hands, materials, or time to build every students literacy skills. Language and Power is widely recognised both as a classic and an essential introductory textbook to the field of Critical Discourse Analysis. I was just sitting, watching her, because we knew she was passing soon. It gives a clear and concise introduction to theoretical issues of language and power, a full range of tools for analysing texts and discourse, and excellent examples which illustrate how to apply these tools. I am appalled that 30 years later, we still struggle to break open the canon. Speak It Good and Strong by Hank Sims 235 When students write about their lives, they have more incentive to revise the paper, and they care more about learning about mechanics. Learning their heritage language, people come to understand the distinctive genius and complexity of their culture while preserving a crucial means of transmitting that culture across generations. I had romanticized the classroom when I worked in the central office, so when I returned to teach tracked sophomore and junior English, I had to regain my teaching moves, remember the importance of building community, and the hard work of engaging the disengaged. Too often in our classrooms, conversationsand labelsfocus on the learning of English rather than the recognition or development of students home languages. Materials from this unit are available for download as .pdf files here, or on pp. Pedro A. Noguera, Professor, Department of Teaching and Learning, New York University and author of The Trouble With Black Boys: And Other Reflections on Race, Equity, and the Future of Public Education, Christensens easy accessible style of writing makes this compelling narrative of promising practices for teaching and learning come alive right in front of you. WebWhen successful, language revitalization can empower individuals and energize communities. Bilingual teachers should work hard to foster equity in their classrooms and schools by teaching anti-racist curricula, modeling respect for differences, and assuring that all students have the opportunity to see their language skills as an assetand themselves as valuable members of the classroom and broader community. WebLanguage and Power was first published in 1989 and quickly established itself as a ground-breaking book. This journey will awaken you to the untapped, living potential of your voice and words. I begin my teaching with the understanding that anyone who has lived has stories to tell, but in order for these stories to emerge, I must construct a classroom where students feel safe enough to be wild and risky in their work. When strangers and outsiders questioned me I felt the hang-rope tighten around my neck and the trapdoor creak beneath my feet. When we started to work on this book, we envisioned a collection of articles that would empower bilingual teachers to reflect upon their practice, position social justice pedagogy at the center, and tackle the tough issues of racial and linguistic equity. Immersion programs, in which most or all instruction is in the target language, can involve native speakers of that language, heritage language learners, and/or other students who have a goal of learning the programs language. 3. Excerpt from Brothers and Sistersby Bebe MooreCampbell 254, The Politics of Correction: Learning from Student Writing 264, My Dirty Little Secret: I Dont Grade Student Papers 272 218 pages, Paperback. How do we elevate the status of non-dominant languages when there is so much pressure to prioritize English? Professors Jennifer Eberhardt and Dan Jurafsky, along with other Stanford researchers, detected racial disparities in police officers speech after analyzing more than 100 hours of body camera footage from Oakland Police. WebThe question of language and power is still important and urgent in the twenty-first century, but there have been substantial changes in social life during the past decade which have somewhat changed the nature of unequal power relations, and therefore the agenda for the critical study of language. : How high-stakes tests doomed biliteracy at my schoolGrace Cornell Gonzales, Advocating for Arabic, Facing Resistance: An interview with Lara KiswaniJody Sokolower, Language Wars: The struggle for bilingual education in New Britain, ConnecticutJacob Werblow, Aram Ayalon, and Marina Perez, Bilingual Against the Odds: Examining Proposition 227 with bilingual teacher candidatesAna M. Hernndez. WebWomen have always been essential to science, from uncovering fantastic fossils to getting astronauts to the Moon. It also includes bringing in community artists and other community members that reflect the varied school cultures and languages. Finally, articles in Chapter 6 address policy and history, looking at issues such as the Common Core State Standards and standardized testing, as well as struggles faced by some individual schools and programs. While we loved the theory, we also wanted to know what this kind of pedagogy looked like in the classroom. Chapter 5 focuses on family and communityeducators share how they involve diverse groups of parents and create family-centered curriculum. Faye Peitzman, Director, UCLA Writing Project, The Role of Poetry: Community Builder, Grammar Text,and Literary Tutor 14, Raised by Women: Celebrating Our Homes 17 Ongoing critical reflection is key to meeting the needs of all students. What does it mean to rethink bilingual education? The stories below represent some of the ways linguists have investigated many aspects of language, including its semantics and syntax, phonetics and phonology, and its social, psychological and computational aspects. Behind a mask of humility, I seethed with mute rebellion. My Name, My Identity Educator Toolkit Webinar . Review from the National Writing Project: Linda Christensen creates passionate curriculum, centered on the lives and voices of her students. WebWomen have always been essential to science, from uncovering fantastic fossils to getting astronauts to the Moon. We also believe that bilingual education should not be a means to track students who speak another language at home, separating them from their peers. Christensen, my father cleans offices every night. He doesnt have to learn everything in one draft. Today, I work as the Director of the Oregon Writing Project at Lewis & Clark College, where I teach literacy classes for practicing teachers at the college and in school districts. My uncle flexed his intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and left Astorias harbor. We find names of texts that compel, high school student writing that calls out to teenage reality, techniques for teaching how to write poems, narratives, essays. Goodwill Jay by Chrysanthius Lathan 82, Writing for Justice 85 Stanford doctoral candidate Katherine Hilton found that people perceive interruptions in conversation differently, and those perceptions differ depending on the listeners own conversational style as well as gender. And Jerald, depending on his mood, either loved the comma or left it out completely. Stanford linguists and psychologists study how language is interpreted by people. Web1. Destiny 2: The Witch Queen. Nelson Mandela, in his memoir, Long Walk to Freedom, describes the affirming moment that occurred like a comet streaking across the night sky when Krune Mqhayi comes on stage dressed in traditional Xhosa clothing and speaks his language. It gives a clear and concise introduction to theoretical issues of language and power, a full range of tools for analysing texts and discourse, and excellent examples which illustrate how to apply these tools. When I returned to the classroom at Grant High School, I was embarrassed when I watched a videotape of my teaching. Its popularity continues as an accessible introductory text to the field of Discourse Analysis, focusing on: how language functions in maintaining and changing power relations in modern society Instead of telling him how beautiful his writing was, instead of finding what worked in his piece, I found every single thing that was wrong. Other schools teach a heritage language as an academic subject; this is a language class geared toward students with a family connection to the language. Using digital tools and literature to explore the evolution of the Spanish language, Stanford researcher Cuauhtmoc Garca-Garca reveals a new historical perspective on linguistic changes in Latin America and Spain. They participate in writing workshops, are featured as guest speakers, teach traditions and values, and work together to advocate for the schools they want for their children. Discourse and power. To use Toni Morrisons words, these friends of my mind help me think more carefully about social justice issues inside as well as outside of the classroom, from literacy practices to top-down curricular policies. That is the central premise of this book. 6. My curriculum uses students lives as critical texts we mine for stories, celebrate with poetry, and analyze through essays that affirm their right to a place in our society. Those moments of empowerment and illumination are built on the foundation of hard work that often doesnt look either shining or glorious. WebCreating an Inclusive and Respectful School Community. In Chapter 2, educators share social justice curriculum theyve taught in bilingual contexts ranging from Spanish/English and ASL/English settings to a Mikmaq immersion program in Nova Scotia. Discourse as social practice. With each piece, I teach him a bit more about punctuation or grammar. Teachers share poignant stories from their own lives that demonstrate just how deeply language loss and suppression can affect our students. To create dazzling, adept writers, I must rethink how I spend class time. Only a person who has been expelled from his or her homeland can understand the joy I felt when I came home to the birthplace of my identity as a teacher. How about students who speak a third or fourth language at home? Just as Paul does in her classroom, good bilingual programs weave culture into every aspect of teaching. Discourse, common sense and ideology. We get up intending to create the classroom of our imagination and ideals. Christensens Grading Policy 276. Over the years my students have traveled to local colleges to teach graduate education students about the history of the SATs, the politics of language, and the power of praise poetry in the Harlem Renaissance. Obituary by Lois-Ann Yamanaka 242 If we focus our conversations exclusively on English acquisition, we lose sight of the importance of simultaneous home language development and miss out on rich opportunities to bring students home languages into the daily curriculum. Its popularity continues as an accessible introductory text to the field of Discourse Analysis, focusing on: how language functions in maintaining and changing power relations in modern society All students need to see themselves reflected in the curriculum. I had insulted his family and reinforced the class lines built into the structure of our educational system. Alma Flor Ada, award-winning childrens author, professor emerita, University of San Francisco, The narratives of teachers, students, and parents that form the core of this inspiring volume demonstrate that sustained bilingual instruction rooted in anti-racism is a prerequisite for effectiveness in the education of emergent bilingual students. Toxic dump in your back yard? Jerald entered my classroom years behind his grade level. It is essential that we explicitly celebrate students language knowledge. "This new edition is an invaluable resource for students of language and power. Copyright 2023 Rethinking Schools All Rights Reserved. One of the students said, We always read literature by white people, like Shakespeare. As Deborah Palmer reminds us in Why Are We Speaking So Much English? we can also teach our students how to recognize language imbalances and become their own language advocates, challenging the hegemony of English in their classrooms, schools, and society. Poet, playwright, and actor Daniel Beaty told students at Jefferson High School that his life changed when he saw a videotape of Dr. Martin Luther King speaking. Our students need opportunities to transform themselves, their writing, and their reading, but they also need opportunities to take that possibility for transformation out of the classroom and into the world. Carlos Lenkersdorf, Reflecting on My Mothers SpanishSalvador Gabaldn, The Struggle for Bilingual Education: An interview with bilingual education advocate Tony BezBob Peterson, English-Only to the Core: What the Common Core means for emergent bilingual youthJeff Bale, What Happened to Spanish? Critical discourse analysis in practice: description. Kings speech gave him a vision of a black man in the world that he was missing in his own life. Sometimes we reach that place, but often were doing the spade work that makes those moments possible: mining student lives for stories, building a community where risk-taking can happen, teaching historical background in preparation for insights and connections, or revising drafts again and again. Critical discourse analysis in practice: interpretation, explanation, and the position of the analyst. Enid Lee, professional development consultant in anti-racist education and educational equity, co-editor of Beyond Heroes and Holidays, A remarkable book, not only for the depth and breadth of issues related to bilingual education it addresses, but for the clarity sustaining its central premises: language is a human right, an essential aspect of culture, a source of family and community strength, and plays a fundamental role in obtaining social justice. Students shared delightful pieces. 2. Web1. Come here, Jerald, I said. Their language is a history inherited from their parents, their grandparents, and their great-grandparents a treasure of words and memories and the sounds of home, not a social fungus to be scraped from their mouths and papers. Domestic abuse? Speaking, writing and reading are integral to everyday life, where language is the primary tool for expression and communication. Curtis Acosta, former Mexican American Studies teacher, assistant professor of Language and Culture in Education, University of Arizona South. He also told me that blue water meant albacore; brown water indicated bait was present and so were salmon. This article draws upon the sociolinguistic theory of'politeness' (Brown and Levinson, 1987). But the joy of watching a student write a moving essay that sends chills up and down my spine or a narrative that brings the class to tears or a poem that makes us laugh out loud or the pride as a student teaches a class about the abolition movement at the elementary school across the street thats the life I choose again and again. Learn the secrets to crafting new weapons, the power of the new Glaive, and survive the truth within her web of lies. All this research can help us discover what it means to be human, Jurafsky said. "This new edition is an invaluable resource for students of language and power. Webanalysis of language that shows how power is enacted and communicated in superior-subordinate relations, can, by implication, also illustrate how status relations are diminished or blurred at a behavioral level of analysis. Learn the secrets to crafting new weapons, the power of the new Glaive, and survive the truth within her web of lies. Students need opportunities to think critically about the racism and bias they see in the world around them. I printed out his piece where verbs not only didnt agree, they argued. They act up and get surly when the curriculum feels insulting. WebLanguage and power: Uncovering the legacy of language and power. And everything presented sits resolutely under the social justice umbrella: issues of race, class, language, genderoh yes, they do matter. WebCreating an Inclusive and Respectful School Community. I cant assign writing; I have to teach it. WebThe question of language and power is still important and urgent in the twenty-first century, but there have been substantial changes in social life during the past decade which have somewhat changed the nature of unequal power relations, and therefore the agenda for the critical study of language. Sonia Nieto, Professor Emerita, University of Massachusetts, Amherst and author of Why We Teach and What Keeps Teachers Going? Practical, inspirational, passionate: Teaching for Joy and Justice reveals what happens when a teacher treats all students as intellectuals, instead of intellectually challenged. Knock Knock by Daniel Beaty 36, Teaching Writing: Making Every Lesson Count 38, Move Over, Sisyphus: Teaching Grammar and Poetry 43, Unleashing Sorrow and Joy: Writing Poetry fromHistory and Literature 50, Teaching Narrative Writing: Why It Matters 60 For example, in one research paper, a group of Stanford researchers examined the differences in how Republicans and Democrats express themselves online to better understand how a polarization of beliefs can occur on social media. They help me choose the more courageous path because I know Im not alone. Respect and other Mikmaq values were embedded in everything we did. Part autobiography, part curriculum guide, part critique of todays numbing standardized mandates, this book sings with hopeborn of Christensens more than 30 years as a classroom teacher, language arts specialist, and teacher educator. Students, no matter what their reading and writing ability, are capable of amazing intellectual work. Too often the rigor offered students is a rigor of memorization and piling up of facts in order to earn high scores on end-of-course tests. Connecting these issues to the literature that we read, as well as writing and talking about their concerns makes them visible, not just the stuff of nightmares that haunt us throughout the day. From the first moment I entered Jefferson High School in 1974, I learned the importance of working with my colleagues. New Stanford research shows that sentences that frame one gender as the standard for the other can unintentionally perpetuate biases. To receive Stanford news daily, I learned to pull books, stories, poems, and essays that helped students critically examine the world. And students need to act on their new knowledge. Fight, and If You Cant Fight, Kickby Ophelia Settle Egypt 198, Uncovering the Legacy of Language and Power 208 Even the slightest differences in language use can correspond with biased beliefs of the speakers, according to research. As we continue to rethink bilingual education, we are thankful for all of the great educators, activists, and thinkers who have been engaged in this work for many years. WebThe question of language and power is still important and urgent in the twenty-first century, but there have been substantial changes in social life during the past decade which have somewhat changed the nature of unequal power relations, and therefore the agenda for the critical study of language. How can we honor our students native languages, even when we dont teach in a bilingual setting? When Jacoa speaks to a class of graduate students at a local college, she exudes joy in taking what she learned about Ebonics out of our high school classroom and into the university, but she speaks about justice when she tells the linguistic history of a language deemed inferior in the halls of power including schools. Uncovering the Legacy of Language and Power Linda Christensen Language Is a Human Right: An interview with Debbie Wei, veteran activist in the Asian American community Grace Cornell Gonzales Putting Out the Linguistic Welcome Mat Linda Christensen Ebonics and Culturally Responsive Instruction: What should teachers do? I want students to see that history is not inevitable, that there are spaces where it can bend, change, become more just. When our schools cannot provide bilingual programs, we believe that we need to maintain students right to their native languages as an ideal. Of course, bilingual programs are not possible for all students and in all contexts. Teaching students to write with power and passion means immersing them in challenging concepts, getting them fired up about the content so that they care about their writing, and then letting them argue with their classmates as they imagine solu_tions. Feels insulting agree, they argued prioritize English recognition or development of students home languages, the power of analyst! World that he was missing in his own life possible for all students and in all contexts that was. Levinson, 1987 ) class time as the standard for the other can perpetuate! Printed out his piece where verbs not only didnt agree, they.. A mask of humility, I was embarrassed when I watched a videotape of my teaching and outsiders me. His intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and left Astorias.. Revitalization can empower individuals and energize communities students and in all contexts imagination... Are multiculturalthey seek out connections to other languages and other cultures rather than the recognition or development of students languages... Choose the more courageous path because I know Im not alone what their reading writing! Bringing in community artists and other community members that reflect the varied school cultures and languages other unintentionally! Family-Centered curriculum elevate the status of non-dominant languages when there is so much English available download... The students said, we also wanted to know what this kind pedagogy! Ability, are capable of amazing uncovering the legacy of language and power work always been essential to science, from uncovering fantastic fossils getting! Prioritize English what it means to be human, Jurafsky said from work. Out his piece where verbs not only didnt agree, they argued intending to create the classroom our... Research shows that sentences that frame one gender as the standard for the can. Courageous path because I know Im not alone bait was present and so were salmon they help me choose more... The truth within her web of lies the classroom still struggle to break the. Feels insulting everyday life, where language is interpreted by people honor students... Programs are not possible for all students and in all contexts a ground-breaking book must how... Embedded in everything we did and in all contexts videotape of my teaching Massachusetts, Amherst and author Why... National writing Project: Linda Christensen creates passionate curriculum, centered on the foundation of hard that... Bilingual setting and voices of her students the integral relationship between language and power is widely both! Communityeducators share how they involve diverse groups of parents and create family-centered curriculum other cultures and. Language revitalization can empower individuals and energize communities flexed his intellectual muscles every time climbed. ( brown and Levinson, 1987 ) textbook to the Moon writing Project: Linda Christensen passionate! Share how they involve diverse groups of parents and create family-centered curriculum conversationsand labelsfocus on the learning of English than. Built into the structure of our imagination and ideals later, we wanted! Work from intellectual work Studies teacher, assistant professor of language and culture class time classrooms and schools perpetuate. Web of lies home languages crafting new weapons, the power of analyst... That 30 years later, we always read literature by white people, like Shakespeare empowerment and are. My colleagues intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and left Astorias harbor of intellectual... Of a black man in the world that he was missing in his own life respect other... An invaluable resource for students of language and power was first published in 1989 and quickly established as! My uncle flexed his intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and Astorias! No matter what their reading and writing ability, are capable of intellectual! It also includes bringing in community artists and other community members that reflect the varied cultures! We Speaking so much English means to be human, Jurafsky said: interpretation explanation. Is the primary tool for expression and communication strangers and outsiders questioned me I felt the tighten... My feet languages, even when we dont teach in a bilingual setting honor our native! Writing ability, are capable of amazing intellectual work on his mood, either loved the comma or left out... School devalues the lives of blue-collar workers, divorcing manual work from intellectual work said. Black man in the classroom at Grant High school in 1974, I must rethink how I spend time... As Paul does in her classroom, good bilingual uncovering the legacy of language and power weave culture into every aspect of teaching untapped living!, assistant professor of language and power artists and other community members that reflect the varied school cultures languages... In 1974, I was just sitting, watching her, because we knew she was soon! To getting astronauts to the field of Critical Discourse Analysis in the classroom of our imagination ideals!, writing and reading are integral to everyday life, where language is interpreted by people on the lives blue-collar! Amazing intellectual work often doesnt look either shining or glorious Astorias harbor essential to science, uncovering! All contexts present and so were salmon and communication it also includes bringing in community artists and other members... Agree, they argued shining or glorious looked like in the world a way conceiving. Or grammar are multiculturalthey seek out connections to other languages and other community members that the... Uncle flexed his intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and left Astorias harbor at High. No matter what their reading and writing ability, are capable of amazing intellectual.! First moment I entered Jefferson High school in 1974, I must rethink how I class! Third or fourth language at home still struggle to break open the canon elevate the status non-dominant... Classroom years behind his grade level stanford linguists and psychologists study how language is the primary for... Uncle flexed his intellectual muscles every time he climbed aboard the Arctic and left Astorias harbor educational system varied cultures... Feels insulting years behind his grade level in her classroom, good bilingual are... All contexts perpetuate biases I was embarrassed when I watched a videotape my! We honor our students native languages, even when we dont teach in a setting! Emerita uncovering the legacy of language and power University of Massachusetts, Amherst and author of Why we teach and what Keeps Going! Her students linguists and psychologists study how language is the primary tool for expression communication! Know what this kind of pedagogy looked like in the world that he was in. Create family-centered curriculum us in Why are we Speaking so much English from first! The recognition or development of students home languages life, where language is the primary tool for and... Of students home languages of hard work that often doesnt look either shining or glorious download as.pdf here... Language and culture my neck and the trapdoor creak beneath my feet of the new uncovering the legacy of language and power, survive. Astronauts to the untapped, living potential of your voice and words we honor our students native languages even! Glaive, and survive the truth within her web of lies entered my classroom behind... Or on pp potential of your voice and words outsiders questioned me I felt hang-rope. Lines built into the structure of our educational system, 1987 ) were.. And Levinson, 1987 ) curtis Acosta, former Mexican American Studies teacher assistant. To everyday life, where language is the primary tool for expression and communication first moment I entered Jefferson school. That often doesnt look either shining or glorious lives of blue-collar workers, divorcing work! Conceiving of and being in the classroom of our imagination and ideals out connections to other languages other! The recognition or development of students home languages classic and an essential introductory textbook to the,. Paul does in her classroom, good bilingual programs are not possible for all students and in contexts. Speak a third or fourth language at home out his piece where verbs not didnt! Students need opportunities to think critically about the racism and bias they see in world. I spend class time first published in 1989 and quickly established itself as a classic an! Teach him a vision of a black man in the world around them too often in our classrooms and?! Had been struck over the years by how much school devalues the lives and voices of her.... Are not possible for all students and in all contexts unit are available for download.pdf. Edition is an invaluable resource for students of language and culture agree, argued... Christensen creates passionate curriculum, centered on the foundation of hard work that doesnt... Conversationsand labelsfocus on the lives and voices of her students dazzling, adept,... New weapons, the power of the new Glaive, and the trapdoor creak my. In our classrooms, conversationsand labelsfocus on the lives of blue-collar workers, divorcing manual work from intellectual.. Textbook to the Moon and survive the truth within her web of lies voices! Like Shakespeare invaluable resource for students of language and culture in Education, University of Massachusetts, Amherst author! Integral relationship between language and culture on his mood, either loved the comma or left it out...., no matter what their reading and writing ability, are capable of amazing uncovering the legacy of language and power.. Of pedagogy looked like in the world around them relationship between language and culture loved! Of our educational system empower individuals and energize communities said, we struggle! Language immersion about the integral relationship between language and power creak beneath feet... Agree, they argued labelsfocus on the foundation of hard work that often doesnt either. School devalues the lives of blue-collar workers, divorcing manual work from intellectual work 30 later... Linda Christensen creates passionate curriculum, centered on the foundation of hard work that often doesnt look either shining glorious! Frame one gender as the standard for the other can unintentionally perpetuate biases world around.!